The Challenge of Implementing Physical Education Mandates
Author’s Note: This post is written about Oregon’s PE Law, Senate Bill 4, and the challenges school districts face when trying to implement mandates. Furthermore, the motivation was inspired by a newspaper article in the East Oregonian that was shared on the SHAPE America Facebook page on 8/31/19. You can read the original article by CLICKING HERE.
Ever since I entered the teaching profession in 2008, a Physical Education law has been considered the utopian policy dream for physical educators everywhere. For years, the state of Illinois was elevated to a pedestal for the work they had done and what was featured in the book SPARK. Unbeknownst to many, Oregon has had a state physical education law as policy since 2007. House Bill 3141, as it was titled then, was considered a huge achievement for the state. In short, it mandated 150 minutes per week of physical education in grades K-5 and 225 minutes per week of physical education in grades 6-8. The bill gave school districts 10 years to plan, prepare and to be in compliance. Unfortunately, there wasn’t a school district in Oregon who didn’t keep kicking the can down the road and hope for days where the law would eventually go away. I can speak to this personally because I began sitting in on meetings with stakeholders at the state level as far back as 2015 to plan for implementation. Compromises were made and full implementation was pushed back again and a phase in model was agreed to. This meant that over a 5 year process, school districts could slowly phase in to the required minutes. The 2019-20 school year is the first year of this phase in with elementary schools K-5 needing to be at 120 minutes. If schools are not in compliance, they do run the risk of having their state funding being withheld (this law has teeth!). This is where things have become interesting.
Over the past several years I have had numerous passionate conversations with physical educators all over the country about physical education mandates and required minutes for physical education. In its most purest form, we all agree with the same general idea:
Physical education should be daily. Every student, in every classroom, in every school, in every school district, in every state should have access to daily physical education at some point during their school day.
I realize I am preaching to the choir with that statement, but as physical educators, we need to get off our high horse. The reality is that change is slow and it is even slower when we are talking about systemic change. When it comes to change, I feel like policy is the easier part. Changing attitudes and perceptions is the tough part. I say this to say that public education is not operating within a utopia. We are operating with budgets, lack of resources, teacher shortages and many other things. Oregon is going to be implementing this PE law with a hodgepodge of solutions that school districts will try. In some districts, they will increase classroom size to double the size of normal classrooms, in some they will put the onus on the classroom teacher to teach up to 45 minutes of the required 120. In some districts, they will create something that they will count as physical education instruction that will much more resemble physical activity than physical education.
There are many physical educators who will have a problem with these implementation plans. They will scream from the roof tops that we should be hiring more physical educators or building more gym spaces so that we can implement this law in its purest form. They will decry this mandate as a bastardization of what should be happening and will consider the law to be an utter failure as a result. The truth is, education doesn’t work like this and it certainly doesn’t change like this overnight. It is an absolute VICTORY for us to be at the table and to be able to finally and legitimately be having these conversations about physical education in our public schools and illuminating our colleagues as to what quality physical education looks and feels like.
We are missing the point if we are looking at physical education mandates with only short term eyes. We shouldn’t be looking at the success or failure of these laws with how it impacts us as professionals. These laws WILL have an impact on the next generation of physical educators who end up replacing us someday when we retire. This is a starting point, but it is not the end. Here is the ugly truth:
There is a significant number of people who are in decision making positions in education who had poor experiences in physical education when they were students.
That is a failure of our profession, but we need to own that. That’s also why we need as many quality physical educators IN THE CLASSROOM as possible. Because we are the ones that will change the attitudes and perceptions of the people who become future leaders in school districts all over the country. The problem now is that educational leaders will give lip service, but they truly don’t see the value of physical education. Our objective should be to try to create small pockets of success that can be replicated and to change minds one person at a time. This is going to take YEARS to accomplish. It’s why what we do is not for the faint of heart.
I am excited that at my school, part of our plan to meet the mandate is to have 40 minutes on one day of the week be school wide physical activity choices that are tied to physical education standards. All staff and all teachers will be helping with this school wide activity. These 40 minutes are designed for students AND for staff. We plan on collecting data around behavior and attendance to support dedicating this time during the school day. Is this quality physical education that is being taught inside a gym by me? No. But, I am very cognizant at just how progressive this idea is in a system that isn’t always progressive. I am confident that there is no way we would have dedicated time to a comprehensive school wide physical activity plan without the impetus of this law.
As physical educators, I think it would better serve us to get outside our own little closed box on what we think quality physical education is and open our minds to flexible possibilities that give us more chances to change hearts and minds for how adults value physical education. It would also help further our efforts in influencing how our students perceive what we do because in no time they will become the ones making decisions around physical education policy.